N1.6bn Fraud: Ex-Jonathan’s Aide, Dudafa, Other To Open Defence on Monday

Browse By

Spread the love

dudafa and Nna Joseph, during one of their appearance after a court session

Justice Mohammed Idris of a Federal High Court, today, fixed next week Monday, for continuation of trial of Dr. Waripamo-Owei Dudafa, a Special Assistant on Domestic Affairs to former President Goodluck Jonathan, and one Iwejuo Joseph Nna, who are standing trial before the court on alleged N 1. 6 billion fraud.

Justice Idris fixed the date, after delivery a bench ruling on the applications filed by the two defendants, asking the court to refer the constitutionality of the trial judge who has been elevated to Court of Appeal, to continue hearing the matter.

The Dudafa and Nna through their lawyers, Mr. Gboyega Oyewole (SAN), Ademola Adefolaju, and Ige Asemudara, also asked the court to suspend trial pending adjudication on the constitutional issued raised.

The defendants in their motion on notice filed before the court, seeking for the two reliefs stated that that by virtue of 1999 Constitution as amended, a Justice of Court of Appeal does not offend the provisions of Section 253 of the Constitution, and rob the Federal High Court of its jurisdiction over the charges pending before it.

POST RECOMMEND FOR YOU   Marginalization: Enugu North Makes Case For Okey Ezea

The two defendants in their motions averred that the issuee of Fiat by the President of the Court of Appeal to a Justice of Court of Appeal, to preside and continue to adjudicate on matter upon which the Federal High Court has jurisdiction does not violate Section 36(1), 239, 240 and 251 of the Constitution, and tinkered with the independence of the Federal High Court.

The defendants also stated that in view of section 295 (2) of the Constitution, a judge who made a reference of question of law touching on jurisdiction to the Appeal Court, can proceed to continue to hear or determined the pending charge wherein the question arose.

They also stated that in view of provision of Sections 34(1)(a)and (c) of the constitution set against the provision of Sections 237, 240, 241, 249, 251, 252 and 253 of the same Constitution, it is not an aberration or degrading treatment to put a Honourable Justice of the Court of Appeal in a situation where he has to mandatorily work by fiat as a judge of Federal High Court.

POST RECOMMEND FOR YOU   N650m Fraud: Akinjide, Others Freely Volunteered Statements -EFCC

Responding, lawyer to the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), Mr. Rotimi Oyedepo, while urging the court to dismissed the applications, submitted that there are three conditions present before a matter can be refer to Court of Appeal in view of section 295 (2) of the Constitution.

The  conditions according to Oyedepo are: Constitution, it must have reason in course of trial, and raising issues of substantial law.

Oyedepo further submitted it is not appropriate to refer an issue to Appeal Court merely because it is been raised for the first to time or it is a matter of general interest. Adding that the Judge is bound not to refer a matter to Court of Appeal, if the interpretation of that law is not that difficult or ambiguous for the court to determine.

Alternately, Oyedepo said that in case the court wants to refer the matter to Court of Appeal, , Section 305, is valid and Constitutional, and that Section 295(2) empowered the court to refer the matter to Court of Appeal but did not preclude the court from assuming jurisdiction in determine the culpability of the defendants on trial, but has the options of proceeding with matter but not delivering verdict on the matter.

POST RECOMMEND FOR YOU   Alleged N2.9bn fraud: EFCC Files More Evidence, Amended Charge Against Kalu, Others

He cited section 306 of Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA) 2015, stater that the court should not suspend proceedings.

Ruling on the submissions of both parties, Justice Idris, after citing several authorities, stated that he will refer the parties’ applications to Court of Appeal, to decide on.

The judge however stated that pending when the Court of Appeal will adjudicate on the parties’  applications, he would continue to hear the matter, consequently, he,adjourned the matter till next week Monday, for the defendants to open their defence.
It would be recalled that both Dudafa and Nna, also known as Ebenezer Taiwo, were arraigned by the EFCC before court on 23-counts of conspiracy to conceal proceeds of crime amounting to over N1.6 billion on June 11, 2013.

Also Read

$300m Fraud: EFCC Urges Court to Dismiss Aiteo, Ot... The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) has urged the Federal High Court, Lagos, to dismiss a fundamental rights suit filed against it by ...
Court Temporary Forfeits Deziani’s N325m Lek... A Federal High Court, Lagos, today, ordered the temporary forfeiture of a landed property belonging to the former Minister of Petroleum Resources,...
Dudafa Asks Court To Acquit Him of Allegations A former Senior Special Assistant to ex-President Goodluck Jonathan on Domestic Affairs, Dr Waripamo-Owei Dudafa has urged the Federal High Court, Lag...
Court Orders Forfeiture of Stolen NIMASA’s £... Justice Saliu Saidu of the Federal High Court, Lagos today, ordered the final forfeiture of the sums of £578,080.00, found by the Economic and F...
NOA, EFCC Set to Adopt Buhari as Anti-Corruption B... As the fight against corruption rages on in the country, the National Orientation Agency (NOA) and the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC)...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Inline
Inline